Was Janie Forced To Marry Logan?

Many readers of Zora Neale Hurston’s novel, Their Eyes Were Watching God, have wondered whether Janie was forced to marry Logan Killicks. In this blog post, we’ll explore the evidence and try to come to a conclusion.

Checkout this video:

Janie’s background and how she came to meet Logan

Janie grew up in a small town in Florida. She was raised by her grandmother, Nanny, who was a former slave. Janie is very attracted to nature, and she often sits under a pear tree in her backyard to think. One day, Janie is sitting under the tree when a handsome stranger named Logan Killicks rides by on a mule. Nanny convinces Janie that she should marry Logan because he is wealthy and can provide for her. Janie goes along with the arranged marriage, but she quickly realizes that she does not love Logan and that he does not understand her.

Janie’s initial impressions of Logan

Janie’s initial impressions of Logan were not good. She thought he was lazy and shiftless and she was not attracted to him. Janie’s grandmother, Nanny, however, thought that Logan would be a good match for Janie. Nanny believed that Janie needed a man who would be able to protect her and provide for her.

The events leading up to Janie’s marriage to Logan

In Their Eyes Were Watching God, set in the early 1900s, marriage is a key theme, particularly for women. For Janie, marriage is a means of escape. She believes that if she marries a man with money, she will be able to lead the life she wants to lead – a life of leisure and luxury. However, her first two marriages do not turn out as she expects.

Janie’s first marriage is to Logan Killicks, an older farmer who owns his own land. Janie’s grandmother, Nanny, arranges the marriage. Logan is not a bad man, but he is not the man of Janie’s dreams. He is too old and too boring for her. Janie feels like she is trapped on his farm and she is not happy.

Logan tries to force Janie to do all the work around the farm while he does nothing. Janie does not want to be a farmer’s wife – she wants to live a life of leisure. She soon realizes that Logan will never give her what she wants and she runs away from him.

Janie’s feelings about being forced to marry Logan

Janie’s feelings about being forced to marry Logan are complicated. On the one hand, she clearly feels pressured by her grandmother and Logan to go through with the marriage. At the same time, however, Janie also seems to genuinely care for Logan and does not want to hurt his feelings. Ultimately, Janie decides to marry Logan, but it is clear that she does not do so entirely of her own free will.

Logan’s perspective on the situation

From Logan’s perspective, he did not force Janie to marry him. He may have asked her frequently and been insistent, but he never actually forced her to do anything. His perspective is that she always had a choice in the matter and that she chose to marry him of her own free will.

How Janie’s friends and family reacted to the news

Janie’s friends and family were shocked when they found out that she was going to marry Logan. They all thought that she was too young and that she should wait a few more years. Janie’s grandmother, Nanny, was the most opposed to the idea. She thought that Janie was being forced into the marriage and that it wasn’t what Janie really wanted.

Janie’s adjustment to married life with Logan

Janie’s adjustment to married life with Logan was difficult at first. She was reluctant to give up her independence, and found it hard to submit to her husband’s authority. However, over time Janie came to see the value in Logan’s protection and leadership, and she began to appreciate the stability that their marriage provided. While Janie may not have initially chosen to marry Logan, she ultimately came to see him as a good husband and a valuable partner.

The challenges Janie and Logan faced as a married couple

Janie and Logan’s marriage was not an easy one. They faced many challenges, both from within and from without. Janie, particularly, had to overcome her own fears and doubts in order to make the relationship work.

Logan, on the other hand, was often impatient with Janie and her need for independence. He wanted a traditional wife who would stay at home and take care of the household duties. This led to many arguments between the two of them.

There were also financial problems. Logan was not a very good provider and often Janie had to work to help make ends meet. This was something that she resented because she felt like she was doing all the work while Logan sat back and did nothing.

In spite of all these challenges, Janie and Logan did love each other. They stuck by each other through thick and thin and were finally able to overcome all the obstacles in their way.

Janie’s eventual decision to leave Logan

Janie’s eventual decision to leave Logan was not entirely her own. While she may have had some desire to leave him, she was also pushed into it by her friends and family. They felt that Logan was not good enough for her and that she deserved better.

Logan’s reaction to Janie leaving him

Logan was not happy when Janie left him. He felt that she had been forced into the marriage and that she had never really loved him. He was angry and hurt and thought that she had betrayed him.

Scroll to Top